Schmudget Blog

"A Shared Vision" Part One: Education and Opportunity

Posted by staceys at Feb 13, 2009 01:25 PM |
Filed under: State Budget

Broadly available education and opportunity is fundamental to the future of our state. Education opens doors to better job opportunities, higher wages, and greater job security. Success in today’s competitive, knowledge-based economy will require more than a basic education. Our children need schools that provide sophisticated, high-quality learning environments so they can graduate with the skills and knowledge to succeed in the global marketplace.

Education begins early and continues throughout adulthood. The Budget & Policy Center has identified four research-based goals within this value area so we can begin to measure our progress towards creating a just and equitable state.

  • Invest in Early Learning
  • Provide a High-Quality Education to All Students
  • Prepare All Adults for Meaningful Careers
  • Cultivate Opportunities for Higher Education

The state has a constitutional mandate to provide a basic education to all students. Most of the funds in the 2007-09 budget that were allocated to Education and Opportunity went towards the goal of providing a high-quality education to all students. The state’s public universities received the next highest amount, followed by workforce training, and then early childhood education. (see graph)


Research continues to show the importance of early childhood education to student success in later grades. A study from the Washington Learns committee (which was co-chaired by Governor Gregoire) found less than half of kids entering kindergarten in the state are adequately prepared for school. Parents generally pay for preschool and child care, which can equal up to 30 percent of a median family income. State and federal programs are designed to assist lower income families with these costs, but in 2006 funding was insufficient in Washington and 42 percent of eligible families went without services.

A high quality K-12 education system depends on good teachers, well-run schools, and challenging course work. Washington has close to 2,000 National Board certified teachers, a credential which requires educators to show a mastery of their subject matter, work closely with parents, and stay abreast of professional theory. The state provides incentives for teachers to achieve the certification and even more if they choose to teach in an under-resourced school.

The state is also working to improve instruction in math and science. Last school year, only half of seventh graders passed the math section of the Washington Assessment of Student Learning (WASL) and in 2006, forty-five percent of students who went directly from a state high school to a community or technical college were required to take remedial math classes. In 2008, the State Board of Education approved a plan to increase the math and science requirements for high school graduation to address these concerns.

Completion of one year of post-high school education and a credential can lead to a significant boost in earnings. A recent survey of Washington businesses found that the highest vacancy rates were for jobs that required more than a high school diploma, but less than a baccalaureate degree. One barrier to continuing education for workers is financial limitations. In 2006-07, the state extended “Opportunity Grants” to 843 lower income workers, most of whom were parents. The program was a success – 73 percent of the grantees completed a full year of school and the program was expanded statewide.

Likewise, affordability can be a significant barrier to lower income students who are interested in higher education. In 2007, Washington enacted a new College Bound Scholarship that notifies students in 7th grade from lower income families that the state will pay the full cost of tuition at any public college or university in the state if they pledge to graduate from high school.

Recent state investments in high quality teachers and improving access to worker training programs have resulted in meaningful progress in education and opportunity in our state. We still face challenges in expanding access to early childhood education and ensuring our students are fully prepared to meet the workforce needs of the new economy. These are investments that will have a lasting impact on the future of our state. We cannot allow the fiscal crisis we now face to derail those efforts.

$3 Billion for Washington State Fiscal Relief

Posted by jeffc at Feb 13, 2009 12:10 PM |
Filed under: State Budget


The federal stimulus package, which may finally be a done deal, includes a number of provisions that will affect Washington State. The two that will have a significant direct effect on the state deficit are an FMAP boost (see my update on that) and the state fiscal stabilization fund. Together, the total is just over $3 billion.

The state fiscal stabilization fund is split into two portions. One is dedicated to education; the other is more flexible. The block grant for education (about $820 million for Washington State) can be used to stabilize state education funding, with any remaining money going to school districts.

The more flexible portion can be used to shore up state funding in other basic services and can also be used for school modernization, renovation, or repair.


More detail on the state fiscal stablization fund can be found here.

UPDATE: Federal Stimulus Requires State Investment in Health Care

Posted by jeffc at Feb 13, 2009 11:00 AM |
Filed under: Health Care, State Budget


Public access to affordable health insurance is especially important during a recession. For many people, the loss of a job means the loss of health care. For those whose jobs didn’t provide health insurance, the loss of income makes health care even less affordable. Now is not the time to cut state investments in the health and well-being of people in Washington.

The federal economic recovery package that is being debated in Congress will likely include an increase in the Federal Medicaid Assistance Percentage (FMAP). This provision will ease some of the pressure on the state budget and allow us to protect other key health programs. But if we’re not careful, budgeting decisions could result in deep cuts in essential services and the forfeiture of some federal funding.

FMAP is the share of Medicaid spending that is covered by the federal government. (Medicaid is the primary source of public health insurance for lower income families across the country. It is funded jointly by states and the federal government.) Washington State’s FMAP is about 50%. So out of the roughly $4 billion spent annually on Medicaid in Washington, the state covers about $2 billion and the federal government covers about $2 billion.

If the recovery bill passes in its current form, federal dollars for Medicaid would rise. We will be able to reduce our state spending on Medicaid without reducing total spending. This would happen through an immediate increase in the state’s FMAP to 60% or perhaps higher. That would mean that the federal government would pay for 60% (instead of 50%) of our $4 billion Medicaid program. The state would only be required to pay 40% (see graph below).


In that scenario, we could reduce our state Medicaid spending from roughly $2 billion to roughly $1.6 billion without cutting people off the program or reducing benefits. This will free up money we would otherwise spend on Medicaid to protect other important health care programs. (Medicaid is only one piece of the health care system in danger due to the deficit.)

A word of caution, however: If we cut Medicaid spending any more than the FMAP increase will cover, we’ll kill the golden goose. Suppose we cut our Medicaid spending by an additional $100 million per year over the amount covered by the recovery package. Because the federal government will only fund 60% of the total funding, the federal share would also fall—by $150 million. We would lose $1.50 in federal funding for every additional $1.00 we cut. It would be a bad move for people suffering from the recession and it would be a bad move for the state economy.


Based on the latest estimates from the Government Accountability Office (GAO), the federal recovery package will increase federal Medicaid spending by $2.06 billion between now and the first quarter of 2011. The state will be able to reduce Medicaid spending by $2.06 billion over the three fiscal years while keeping total spending on the program constant. The money will be divided among fiscal years as shown in the graph below, according to the GAO.


A Shared Vision for Washington State: Four-Part Series

Posted by staceys at Feb 13, 2009 06:25 AM |
Filed under: State Budget, BPC News

Later today schmudget will post the first in a four-part, Friday series that outlines a shared vision for Washington State. The Budget & Policy Center recently published a report called the Progress Index which sets up a new framework for evaluating the state budget based on shared values and goals. The framework reminds all of us that we have a shared responsibility to create the state we want to live in. Together we must ensure that our air is clean, our drinking water is safe, and our public schools provide an excellent education to all students. This is work we must do together because no one person can do it alone.

The Progress Index highlights four essential values: Education and Opportunity, Thriving Communities, Healthy People and Environment, and Economic Security. The report divides the 2007-09 state budget into these four value areas (see graph) and identifies research-based goals within each area.


In these times of economic crisis, it is possible to lose sight of the important role of state investments in all our lives. We are all feeling the pinch of the recession, at home, at work, and in our state government. We must be thoughtful in our investments and make smart choices to protect the progress we’ve made and secure a better future for tomorrow.

You are welcome to read the report and share your thoughts with us. With this project, we hope to initiate a new conversation in Washington State about where we are, where we want to be, and how we can get there.

General Assistance: New Strategies for a Vital Program

Posted by staceys at Feb 11, 2009 10:00 AM |
Filed under: Economic Security

gauss.pngToday the Budget and Policy Center released a new policy brief on Washington State's General Assistance - Unemployable (GA-U) program. The paper, entitled, "General Assistance: New Strategies for a Vital Program," outlines the value of GA-U, which offers economic security and health care to over 20,000 working-age adults with disabilities in our state. The Governor has proposed eliminating the program, a proposal that would have a very detrimental effect.

In addition, the paper discusses how GA-U could better serve clients through implementing strategies that will improve outcomes and reduce costs. Included in these proposals are:

  • Provide a medical home for every GA-U client
  • Expand coverage for mental health and substance abuse treatment
  • Improve state facilitation of eligible GA-U clients to federal programs
To read the full text, go here.

Family Resources and Work Supports: An Online Tool

Posted by jeffc at Feb 10, 2009 07:50 AM |
Filed under: Economic Security

Public programs that ensure economic security can have a big influence on family budgets, as evidenced by an online tool that simulates the effects of work supports on the budgets of hypothetical families.

The Budget and Policy Center has partnered with the National Center for Children in Poverty (a think tank based at Columbia University's School of Public Health) on a "Family Resource Simulator" for Washington State. An updated version of the FRS was released this morning.

The Family Resource Simulator demonstrates the impact of work supports such as the Earned Income Tax Credit, child care subsidies, and public health insurance on a family budget. It allows the user to choose a location within the state, a marital status, the number and age of children in the family, debts, and assets. You can also decide which work supports you would like to consider. The calculator comes preloaded with typical expenses for areas such as transportation and health insurance, but also allows you to enter your own assumptions.

When you've entered all your choices, the simulator produces graphs that indicate how public supports would intersect with family budgets and how expenses and resources change as wages increase.

The example below shows the budget for a single mom with two young children living in Pierce County if she had no access to any work supports. According to the calculator, she would have to earn a considerable salary before resources are sufficient to meet expenses (over $50,000).


This next graph considers the same family, but allows access to work supports in cases where the family is eligible.* Under this scenario, resources cover expenses at a much lower income level (about $24,000).


* The two graphs (generated by the FRS) have different scales - the top one goes from $0 to $60,000 and the bottom goes from $0 to $70,000.

Note that the FRS is a public policy analysis tool. It shouldn't be used to determine a real family's eligibility for public assistance.

We Need a Strong Recovery, Quick

Posted by jeffc at Feb 06, 2009 12:10 PM |

For workers with lower and moderate hourly wages, the current recession comes at a precarious time. The losses in income that workers are expected to incur now come on the heels of an insufficient recovery from the last recession in 2001.

The graph below shows the growth in average hourly wages for the lower-earning half of the Washington State workforce. Wages are adjusted for inflation.


There are three very different time periods:

BOOM: Low unemployment and robust job growth translated to strong wage growth in the last half of the 1990s.

BUST: After adjusting for inflation, there was no wage growth among lower and moderate wage workers.

BUSTED BOOM: When job growth started to rebound after the 2001 recession, wage growth improved, but stayed very anemic.

We only have comparable wage data through 2008 at this point, but it’s a safe bet that wages are taking another hit. Looking ahead, not only can workers not afford this recession, they can’t afford another recovery like the last one.

* Data is based on analysis of CPS-ORG microdata, following the methodology used in State of Working America. Want more detail? Let me know.

Document Actions

Sign Up for #BudgetMatters17!

We will host two Budget Matters policy summits this year – one in Spokane on October 31 and one in Seattle on December 6! 

Our Policy Priorities

Washington state should be a place where all our residents have strong communities, great schools, and the chance for a bright future. Our 2017-2019 Legislative Agenda outlines the priorities we are working to advance to build a better Washington.

Budget Beat!

Check out the Budget Beat webinars we hosted throughout the 2017 legislative session, including our most recent Budget Beat about federal budget proposals, featuring Louisa Warren of the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities, on our YouTube channel

Testimonies in Olympia

To advance our legislative priorities, the Budget & Policy Center team was in the state capitol throughout session testifying on a wide range of bills. Watch our testimonies on TVW:
Misha TVW