Schmudget Blog
— filed under:

Skipping Pension Payments: Wrong Path to Sustainable State Budget

Posted by taral at Mar 13, 2012 05:55 PM |
Filed under:

By Michael Mitchell   As the budget debate rages in Olympia, some lawmakers are calling for dramatic changes to the pension system for teachers, child protective service case workers, parole counselors, and other public-sector employees in Washington state. Proponents of the changes argue they are needed to improve budget “sustainability.” In reality, our public pension system is on stable financial ground, and the proposed changes could lead to higher costs in the future.

Proposed Senate Bill 6378, would impose significant changes to the state pension system -- including temporarily suspending state and local pension payments to specific retirement plans for fiscal year 2013, closing a defined benefit plan, and requiring future state employees to join a hybrid defined benefit/defined contribution plan.

Those who argue in favor of these changes fail to account for the following factors:

Public pensions are on solid financial ground: A 2010 study by the Office of the State Auditor showed that the state’s pension system is funded at a 99 percent level overall.  Only New York and Wisconsin were estimated to have higher pension ratios.

Small savings now; big costs down the line: Skipping the pension payment would result in $147 million in near-term savings. However, in the long run, the skipped payment would lead to additional pension costs of nearly $500 million over the next 25 years. This means that future pension contributions would have to be increased to make up for suspended current payments.

Proposed changes could threaten credit rating: Pension funding levels are a key component of our state’s credit rating. In recent years, rating agencies have cited our well-funded pension plans as a major credit strength of the state while at the same time citing use of one-time budget fixes in previous biennia as a major weakness. Skipping a pension payment would reduce the system’s funding levels, which could lead to a downgrade in our credit rating. If rating agencies were to downgrade Washington’s credit rating by one notch – from AA+ to AA – the office of the State Treasurer estimates additional interest costs at over $110 million for the state over four years.

“Hybrid-plan” may not save money: While the official fiscal impact statement for SB 6378 indicates that in total, the legislation would save the state approximately $623 million over 25 years, it also points out that if future investment returns are lower than expected or if baseline projections are altered, those projected savings could transform into future state costs of approximately $3.3 billion over the same time span.

Legislators are right to be concerned with the sustainability of our budget. However, this proposal fails to address the single most important factor in building a truly sustainable state budget: fixing Washington’s flawed revenue system. If we are to make the continued investments necessary to support the public safety, education and health structures we all rely on, legislators should support new revenues that allow us to do so.   

Document Actions

Our Legislative Agenda

The Budget & Policy Center's 2015-17 Legislative Agenda calls for an equitable and sustainable revenue system in addition to state investments that will promote a world-class education system; sustain a strong, inclusive middle class; produce high-quality, living wage jobs, and ensure equal opportunity to live healthy and productive lives. Take a closer look here.

Testimonies in Olympia

Andy testimonyWe've testified in support of a number of important bills this session. Take a look:

Budget Beat

In our February 27 Budget Beat webinar, State Rep. Reuven Carlyle, D-Seattle, and Senior Fiscal Analyst Andy Nicholas talked about the tax break transparency bill. 

In our February 6 webinar, State Sen. Pramila Jayapal, D-Seattle, and Research and Policy Analyst Lori Pfingst discussed the proposal to raise the state's minimum wage to $12. 

Budget Matters Conference

Thank you to all those people who made our 3rd Annual Budget Matters Conference a success! Take a look at this video highlighting Budget Matters 2014.