Schmudget Blog
— filed under: ,

Volatility Claims for Capital Gains Reform Are Overblown

Posted by Andy Nicholas at Mar 23, 2015 08:20 PM |

Those who are against higher taxes on the richest households in Washington state frequently claim that large year-to-year fluctuations in revenue collections or “volatility” are a reason to oppose Governor Inslee’s proposal to tax high-end capital gains. While capital gains do fluctuate to a larger extent than other revenue sources, the proposed tax would have only a small impact on the overall volatility of Washington state’s tax system. The bottom line? Policymakers don’t have to sacrifice the many benefits of taxing capital gains to address a minor increase in overall revenue fluctuations.

Washington has one of the more stable state tax systems in the nation, according to data from The Pew Charitable Trusts. All state tax systems rise and fall in concert with the economy to some extent. Revenue collections under Washington state’s current tax system swung 5.3 percentage points above or below their average growth trend between 2004 and 2013 (Figure 1). Thirty states had more volatile tax systems than Washington.

2015_tax_volatility_rank
 

Adding a capital gains tax to Washington’s revenue mix during this period would have slightly increased short-term volatility, causing total tax collections to fluctuate 6.3 percentage points above or below their overall growth trend. Even so, the state’s tax system would have remained among the most stable in the nation. With the capital gains tax, Washington’s ranking would have increased to 27th most volatile from 31st, or among the middle of the pack.

Further, as Figure 2 shows, a capital gains tax would account for a small portion (less than 5 percent in most years) of total tax revenues in Washington state. More-stable revenue sources, such as the state property tax and the business and occupation (B&O) tax, would continue to dominate the tax system, keeping overall revenue volatility low.

TotalRevenue_CapGains

There are many ways policymakers could offset the small increase in short-term revenue volatility that would come with a capital gains tax. They include:

  • Dedicating a portion of capital gains tax revenues to the rainy day fund. As we have written previously, increasing the constitutionally protected Budget Stabilization Account (the “rainy day fund” the state sets aside) would help ensure funding for schools, health care, and other investments remains stable in the long run.
  • Using the volatile portion of capital gains tax revenues to fund one-time investments. The Governor’s proposal would reliably generate about $350 million per year, regardless of economic conditions. That portion could be used to fund schools and other ongoing priorities. Any revenues above $350 million could be used for one-time expenses, such as constructing new schools and other public facilities.

Read more about the many benefits of the capital gains tax proposal.

Document Actions
HIGHLIGHTS

GiveBig logo for web 2017

GiveBIG Is May 10!

A gift to the Washington State Budget & Policy Center supports our work to advance a just and prosperous state for all Washingtonians! Early giving starts on April 27.

 

We're Seeking Board Members

Want to engage more deeply with the work of the Budget & Policy Center? Then consider joining our Board of Directors! We are looking for three new board members this year. Click here for details.

Watch Our Budget Beat Webinars

We host regular Budget Beat webinars throughout legislative session to bring you updates and breaking news from Olympia and timely policy analysis. Visit our YouTube channel to watch our previous Budget Beats. 

Testimonies in Olympia

To advance our legislative priorities, the Budget & Policy Center team is in the state capitol throughout session testifying on a wide range of bills. Watch our recent testimonies on TVW:
Misha TVW

View Our School Funding Plenary 

Roxana_BMC_plenary_2016View the Budget Matters 2016 conference plenary, "What's at Stake in the 2017-2019 Budget: Funding McCleary and Beyond." Moderated by Ann Dornfeld of KUOW, the plenary features Nathan Gibbs-Bowling, the 2016 Washington State Teacher of the Year; Lew Moore of the Washington Research Council; Roxana Norouzi of OneAmerica; and Sen. Christine Rolfes. The plenary starts after an intro by Executive Director Misha Werschkul and an intro video by Gov. Inslee.